Preakness Picks: Betting on the Second Jewel of the Triple Crown

The Preakness is often mistaken as the “simpler” leg of the Triple Crown because of its shorter field. But fewer entries don’t mean fewer variables. In fact, they tend to make the margin for error even smaller.

Every move, every post draw, and every shift in betting odds carries more weight. And in that pressure cooker, the bettors who understand form cycles, pace collapse potential, and trainer patterns start to stand out.

That’s why it’s not just about who you like. It’s also about how you bet. Let’s start by breaking down the types of wagers that set the foundation for any smart Preakness play.

Best Bonuses

BetOnline

50% Bonus up to $1000

No Code Promo Code 50% Bonus

BetAnySports

150% Bonus - Reduced Juice

No Code Promo Code 150% Bonus

Bet105

Reduced Juice Lines (-105)

No Code Promo Code Deposit $5 | Get $25 Free

Let’s Talk Wagers

Before you start picking horses, you’ve got to know how your money moves. That starts with knowing the different types of bets and how each one plays into your larger strategy. Once you're ready to put your insights to work, it matters where you bet.

Many experienced players choose to bet with FanDuel, among other reliable platforms, for access to dynamic odds and fast-moving markets that reflect real-time shifts in public and expert sentiment. But before placing anything, you’ll want to ensure the type of wager you choose matches your vision of the race unfolding.

A win bet is the most straightforward, as you’re only betting on a horse to finish first. Place means the horse can finish first or second, and the show gives you a return if the horse finishes anywhere in the top three. These basic bet types are lower risk and suitable for steady plays.

But the real opportunities lie in exotic wagers. An exacta means picking the top two finishers in the exact order. A trifecta is much more complex as you must predict the top three. Then there’s the superfecta, which requires nailing the top four.

These bets are harder to hit but offer much bigger payouts. The Preakness’s compact yet fierce field creates the perfect storm for exotic wagers to hit big, especially for those who’ve put in the prep.

The key is knowing when to keep it simple and when to go big. Basic bets might be the better move in races with clear standout contenders. But if there’s value in the mid-tier or a live longshot, exactas and trifectas can pay off.

Reading Form, Focus, and the Human Factor

There’s much more to betting than just picking the horse with the best name or flashiest record. Past performance matters a lot. Look at how a horse has run at similar distances and track surfaces.

Has it handled pressure in tight finishes? Did it have a clean trip or face traffic? All of these give clues about how it might run at Pimlico.

The pre-race condition also plays a big role. Watch for workout reports in the days leading up to the race. A horse that’s hitting its stride in the mornings is usually sharp. And don't overlook the post position. While Pimlico’s track doesn’t have quite the bias seen at other courses, the rail can be tricky in a fast-paced race.

The jockey matters more than most casual bettors realize. Some jockeys ride Pimlico well. Others have chemistry with specific horses that show up in the results.

Knowing which pairings have a history together and how they’ve done in pressure situations is valuable insight. If a jockey has done well with a horse coming from off the pace, and the Preakness sets up with a hot early tempo, that pairing might be primed to strike.

And then there’s the Derby effect. Horses exiting the Kentucky Derby often take money simply for being in the big show. But the real angle is how they exited. Did they have a troubled trip? Did they close well despite the traffic? Horses improving late in the Derby often shine in the Preakness. That’s something sharp bettors track closely.

Making Sense of the Numbers

Odds in horse racing aren’t just payout indicators. They tell a story about public perception and value. A horse at 2-1 is a clear favorite, meaning bettors believe it has the best chance to win.

But that doesn’t always reflect reality. Favorites lose more often than they win. So, looking past the top line is critical.

Horses with longer odds can offer real upside, especially if their past performances show improvement or hidden strength. Maybe a horse had a wide trip in its last race but still gained ground late. Maybe it switched barns recently and has been working sharper ever since. These little details can be signs of a sleeper.

Informed bettors look at more than just who’s popular or who won last time. They study things like how fast a horse usually runs, how the race might play out, and how the horse handled tough spots in past races. They try to find horses that are better than their odds suggest. That’s how they spot real betting value. And by watching how the odds change leading up to race day, they can often tell where the experts are putting their money.

Stacking the Odds in Your Favor

Track conditions at Pimlico often fly under the radar but can make or break a bet. Pimlico’s surface can dry out quickly but is notoriously shallow and tiring if it rains. That gives a big edge to horses with proven stamina or past success on off-tracks. If you're not accounting for that, you're missing part of the equation.

Another crucial piece? Bankroll management. It’s easy to get carried away on Preakness Day, especially with many tempting bets on the card. Pros set a budget and stick to it. They decide in advance how much they’ll risk on win bets, how much on exotics, and what they’ll walk away from if the odds shift too far.

Diversifying your bets can also smooth out the risk. Instead of dropping everything on one trifecta, split your stake between several combinations. Maybe back a longshot to place while boxing an exacta with a pair of strong closers. These layered approaches increase your chances of winning without needing a perfect pick.

Wrapping Up

There’s a reason smart bettors circle the Preakness on their calendar. It’s the race where sharp observation meets a limited margin for error. With so much compressed into a two-week turnaround, this is where preparation matters most. When you factor in how quickly narratives change post-Derby, how betting markets shift in real-time, and how weather plays its hand, your picks stop being guesses and become informed investments.

I (AKA CatBurg) have a lifelong passion for sports, especially football and basketball. I enjoy the thrill and excitement of sports betting and everything in between. My teams are (Packers #GoPackGo) and who I am betting on!