Odds for Craziest Super Bowl 59 Prop Bets

Coin Toss Chaos

The coin toss is the simplest Super Bowl prop, but it draws as much attention as any prop on the board. The odds sit tightly around -105 for both heads and tails, a classic 50-50 shot. It doesn’t get more straightforward—or random—than this. Yet, bettors have poured millions annually into this market, making it a top-10 Super Bowl prop year after year. Tails currently holds a slight edge over the past 11 Super Bowls, landing heads-up in six of those contests.

Beyond the toss result, sportsbooks also stir the pot with props like which team wins the toss or whether the coin-toss caller guesses correctly. Sharps tend to steer clear of this “pure luck” prop, but casual bettors embrace the fun. With nothing but chance at stake, this is a “let it ride” type of wager.

Best Bonuses

BetOnline

50% Bonus up to $1000

No Code Promo Code 50% Bonus

BetAnySports

150% Bonus - Reduced Juice

No Code Promo Code 150% Bonus

Bet105

Reduced Juice Lines (-105)

No Code Promo Code Deposit $5 | Get $25 Free

A Gatorade Shower of Speculation

Few moments are as viral as the Gatorade bath that baptizes the winning coach. But predicting the color is a gamble in its own right, and it has become one of the most entertaining props. Orange, yellow, purple, blue, and even clear have all been dumped in past title games, though orange has held a fond reputation recently thanks to a few repeat performances.

This bet has no connection to the game itself, making it the ultimate “why not” wager for fans. Odds are released by sportsbooks closer to game day, building suspense while everyone tries to decipher old footage of Gatorade tubs on the sidelines.

Quirky Prop Bets That Steal the Spotlight

Super Bowl prop bets don’t end with scoring plays and Gatorade showers. Odds are usually available for less conventional bets too, like predicting the performer’s first song during the halftime show or the total number of commercials aired during the game. These quirky bets have gained popularity among casual bettors who treat them as a fun way to engage with the event.

Platforms offering these unique props cater to audiences seeking all kinds of action, from traditional lines to these novelty options. If you’re hunting for entertaining ways to bet while also trying to save a buck, exploring sports betting promos alongside other curated offerings can be a great starting point.

National Anthem Stopwatch

The national anthem is another prop bettors circle early, especially when the singer’s tempo tendencies are up for debate. Historically, veteran singers tend to linger on the final note, but each year’s anthem is unpredictable, especially as sportsbooks evaluate previous performance timing.

Commercials Take a Turn

Prop betting even ventures into broadcasting quirks, like which car brand will air the first commercial or the total number of ads during the game. These entertain the crowd as much as the event on the field and turn every ad break into another opportunity to cash in.

MVP Thank-You Shenanigans

The MVP often has a microphone in hand minutes after the clock hits zero, and bettors can wager on who they’ll thank first. Teammates, coaches, God, and family members are common favorites, but media questions sometimes alter the speech trajectory, making this another unpredictable market.

Offensive and Defensive Plays

Traditional props hold their ground, targeting strategic aspects of the game, like the first offensive play call, the first scoring play, or the total receiving yards of a standout player. Bettors can also go for high-risk wagers, like predicting if a kicker will hit the uprights during an attempt.

Defensive props also enter the mix, with sportsbooks offering odds on whether there will be a touchdown caused by a turnover or if a specific defender records a sack.

Player-Centric Madness

While casual bettors gravitate toward popular stars, seasoned bettors focus more on value and matchups. Props with yes/no or over/under lines avoid the higher vig often baked into exotic player scenarios.

Super Bowl props have carved a niche as a unique way to bet on football’s biggest stage. From coin toss randomness to quirky entertainment bets, the variety ensures something for everyone, regardless of how much they know—or care—about what’s happening on the field.

I (AKA CatBurg) have a lifelong passion for sports, especially football and basketball. I enjoy the thrill and excitement of sports betting and everything in between. My teams are (Packers #GoPackGo) and who I am betting on!